top of page

The Limits of Bail Reform in Canada

Writer: Featured in Robson Crim
Featured in Robson Crim
4 hours ago
7 min read

Author: Ben Baydock


Introduction

Bail reform has become a hot topic in Canadian politics. Every week we see stories about people out on bail committing more crimes. For example, on September 4, 2025, a man stabbed eight people on Hollow Water First Nation in Manitoba, resulting in a death of a person. [i] At the time of the stabbing, the male was out on bail for charges of assault with a weapon and mischief, and he had previous convictions for assault.[ii] At face value, it appears the circumstances raise questions about whether release on bail was appropriate.The presumption does not consider several factors that will be discussed, including issues around the imprisoning of innocent people, correctional facility overcrowding, and the time it takes for cases to get to trial. These factors raise questions about whether bail reform alone can effectively address Canada’s broader problems with crime and the criminal justice system.


Bail and Issues with Release

Before examining the potential problems associated with bail reform holding the accused prior to trial, it is also important to consider that this may be a problem. First, let’s outline what bail is to begin with. According to the Department of Justice, “[b]ail is when a person charged with a criminal offence is released from custody while awaiting their trial.”[iii] The Criminal Code outlines the purposes of bail as:


1.     Ensuring the accused appears in court;

2.     Maintaining public safety by minimizing the risk an accused person poses; and

3.     Maintaining the public’s confidence in the justice system.[iv]


A judge has the final say over whether a person is released on bail and what conditions, if any, are imposed on the accused. The Supreme Court outlined in R v St-Cloud that, “in Canadian law, the release of accused persons is the cardinal rule and detention, the exception.”[v] This means that judges across the country are required to assume the person can be released, unless the prosecutor can make a compelling case for why they should be held in custody while awaiting their trial. Now that we know what bail is, we can consider why the current situation may be problematic. There is evidence to suggest that bail and conditions of release are not preventing people from committing additional crimes. Almost everyone may hear the phrases, “released on an undertaking” or “the accused was out on bail” in news reports, but how widespread is the problem?


According to the Department of Public Safety’s 2023 report, in the 2022-2023 reporting cycle, 22,152 people were charged with failure to comply with an order, and another 4,154 people were charged with failure to appear.[vi] Together these two offences made up around 12% of the 215,038 total charges laid in that time.[vii] Additionally, at 10.3%, failure to comply with an order was the second most charged offence in the country.[viii] These statistics outline the reasons why Canadians may be dismayed with the current bail system. These figures suggest that there are significant challenges with repeat offenders that is not being addressed, and politicians and the public have been calling for the system to be reformed.


The Imprisonment of Innocent People

A serious issue surrounding the idea of limiting bail and holding most people in custody before their trial is the imprisonment of innocent people and the implication of guilt. The most important thing to consider is the implications bail reform would have on the freedom of Canadians. The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms (the “Charter”)provides that anybody charged with an offence has both the right to not be denied reasonable bail without justification and the presumption of innocence until they are proven guilty.[ix] An attempt by any government, provincial or federal to limit the ability of an accused to seek bail would bring up serious Charter issues, and most likely result in the law being deemed unconstitutional as the court has already established that releasing an accused should be the default position of the courts.[x] A ruling that bail reform is unconstitutional would leave us in the same spot we are now, but with the courts facing added pressure from the public. Additionally, making the accused prove they should be let out on bail takes away the innocent until proven guilty assumption by forcing them to justify why they should be released.


We must consider the fact that an overwhelming number of people in provincial jails are awaiting trial. Across the country, around 71% of people incarcerated are awaiting trial.[xi] This fact directly contradicts the idea that everyone is being released and shows that our current system, despite its apparent flaws, is holding a significant number of people accused of violent offences during the pretrial phase. In fact, the number of people being denied bail in Canada has risen over 50% in the last 40 years.[xii] This suggests that the existing system is already resulting in significant levels of pretrial detention to keep violent offenders off the streets, but that the system is stretched thin and is creating backlogs in our correctional facilities, which, in some cases, are resulting in lesser sentences being imposed due to the conditions that people who are legally assumed to be innocent are being placed in while awaiting trial.[xiii]


Procedural Hurdles

The causes of several of the issues outlined above may be because of procedural delays. The court systems are overloaded with high caseloads, causing people to wait years for cases to go to trial. In the meantime, they are either out on bail or locked up in overcrowded correctional facility that are reaching a “state of crisis.”[xiv] Looking at the example from the start of this blog, the accused was released on bail awaiting trial on violent crime charges at the start of June and committed another crime in September.[xv] While the turnaround time in this example is not over a year, it is also not the next day. It brings up the idea that violent crimes should be tried quickly so that if the accused is guilty, they don’t have a long period of time to commit another offence. On the flip side, if the accused is innocent, they would have their name cleared in an expeditious fashion.


The Charter outlines that everyone is entitled to be tried within a reasonable time, and the Supreme Court established a ceiling on the amount of time a case has to proceed though the court system.[xvi],[xvii] The ceiling outlined in R v Jordan is set at 18 months for cases heard in provincial court, where more than 95% of criminal proceedings are heard.[xviii] With such a tight timeline and a court system that is stretched thin, we are seeing an increasing number of cases being thrown out due to court backlog. In 2023 and 2024, more than 400 cases were thrown out across the country due to the timelines set out in the Jordan decision.[xix] If that many cases are being thrown out over delays, this raises questions about whether bail reform alone is necessary or sufficient. It doesn’t make sense to hold people without bail for 18 months, just to release them when their cases don’t get to court in time. Something fundamental needs to change or this will be the reality once the federal government passes their bail reform plan.


Conclusion

In conclusion, while there may be legitimate concerns with Canada’s current bail system, expanding pretrial detention may not address the underlying problems within the criminal justice system. It sounds like a good idea, and it is something politicians are pushing for arguably because of the optics, but how is the public going to react when their tax dollars may be used to build temporary detention facilities and people accused of violent offences are being released while awaiting trial?


The evidence suggests that Canada’s challenges may lie less with bail itself and more with an ineffective judicial process. Delays in the court system can result in people being released on bail for extended periods while awaiting trial, potentially giving some individuals opportunities to reoffend. At the same time, correctional facilities are already facing capacity pressures due to the large number of people being held before trial. There is no easy fix. Addressing the backlog would likely require additional judges, prosecutors, and court staff, but increasing these resources would take time. As a result, the government may pursue bail reform in response to public concerns and pressure for immediate action. However, questions remain about whether the proposed changes will address the underlying issues within the justice system while continuing to protect individual rights.  


Image Description: A stark prison corridor with metal bars, beige and pale green walls, evoking a sense of confinement and isolation.
Image Description: A stark prison corridor with metal bars, beige and pale green walls, evoking a sense of confinement and isolation.

Endnotes:

[i] Brittany Hobson & Steve Lambert, “Man who killed sister in Manitoba mass stabbing was out on bail: court records” (5 September 2025), CTV News Winnipeg, online: <ctvnews.ca/winnipeg> [perma.cc/GLE9-4CMB].

[ii] Ibid.

[iii] Department of Justice Canada, “Backgrounder: The Bail Process” (16 October 2025), online: Government of Canada <justice.gc.ca> [perma.cc/MS9N-VE9X].

[iv] Criminal Code, RSC 1985, c C-46, s 515(10).

[v] R v St-Cloud, 2015 SCC 27 at para 70 [St-Cloud], online: < https://canlii.ca/t/ghtd9 >.

[vi] Public Safety Canada, 2023 Annual Report Corrections and Conditional Release Statistical Overview (Ottawa: PSC, 2025) at 50-51 online: Government of Canada <publicsafety.gc.ca> [perma.cc/7LR2-DFFN].

[vii] Ibid at 51.

[viii] Ibid at 49.

[ix] Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, ss 11(d)–(e), Part I of the Constitution Act, 1982, being Schedule B to the Canada Act 1982 (UK), 1982, c 11.

[x] St-Cloud, supra note iv at para 70.

[xi] Dale Smith, “Proposed bail reforms will imprison innocent people”, National (23 October 2025), online: <nationalmagazine.ca> [perma.cc/79C7-TNTH].

[xii] Ibid.

[xiii] Ibid.

[xiv] Ibid.

[xv] Hobson & Lambert, supra note i.

[xvi]Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, supra note 8 at s 11(b).

[xvii] R v Jordan, 2016 SCC 27 at para 49, online: < https://canlii.ca/t/gsds3>.

[xviii] Ibid at para 49.

[xix] Darryl Greer, “Time limits for trials were meant to speed up justice. They’ve also halted hundreds of criminal cases”, CBC News British Columbia (10 November 2024), online: <cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia> [perma.cc/6N53-CYEE].

  • Facebook Basic Black
  • Twitter Basic Black

© 2023 Jochelson, Trask

The content on this website is provided for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal or other professional advice or an opinion of any kind. Users of this website are, in all matters, advised to seek specific legal advice by contacting licensed legal counsel for any and all legal issues. Robsoncrim.com does not warrant or guarantee the quality, accuracy or completeness of any information on this website. All items and works published on this website, regardless of their original date of publication, should not be relied upon as accurate, timely or fit for any particular purpose.

bottom of page