top of page

R v Pendl 2019 MBCA 89

E Ferguson - law student
Dec 13, 2019
4 min read

Updated: 7 days ago

Author:E Ferguson


R v Pendl was heard in the Manitoba Court of Appeal and released on September 4th, 2019. The accused was convicted of break, enter and commit robbery (section 348(1)(b) of the Criminal Code) and forcible confinement (section 279(2)). He sought leave to appeal and wanted to appeal his sentence of eight years incarceration less the three months he already served.


The reason the accused sought appeal was that he believed an error in law was made when the judge did not caution the jury when hearing testimony from a witness who was also an accomplice in the crime. This warning procedure is known as the Vetrovec warning.


Facts

In an incident lasting approximately two hours, the accused, Mr. Johnston, and an unnamed driver committed a break and enter at the property of an elderly man in rural Manitoba. Wearing masks and armed with knives, the men knocked the victim unconscious and tied his hands as they ransacked the house for valuables. When leaving the property, they freed the elderly man’s hands, cut the phone line, and slashed the victim’s tire. They stole a set of hunting knives from the property. The victim was injured during the incident, and in addition to having to spend time in hospital, the trauma of the event has made him unable to return to his home since.


History of the Procedure

One of the reasons that the accused was seeking appeal was that the trial judge “failed to caution herself in accordance with Vetrovec v The Queen [1982] 1 SCR 811, regarding the testimony of both Mr. Johnston and the girlfriend”. The Vetrovec warning was born from a case concerning a conspiracy to traffic heroin that hinged on the testimony from accomplices to the crime. It is a principle in Canadian criminal law that allows for a judge to give a “clear and sharp” warning to jurors when they deem a witness who is giving testimony to be unsavoury, alerting the jury that special attention needs to be given to the testimony. It usually applies to witnesses who are accomplices or who have a “demonstrable moral lack”. There are two questions a judge may consider if they want to give the warning; first, does the evidence of the witness need special scrutiny?


Second, is the character of the witness such that their evidence should be brought into serious question? When the warning is given, the jury is told that although they are entitled to consider the evidence they will hear, it is dangerous to do so. A judge has complete discretion as to whether they want to give this warning to a jury.


Testimony

The accused was convicted largely in part due to the testimony of the co-accused, Mr. Johnston, who entered into a plea deal, as well as the testimony of his girlfriend, who he used as an alibi. The testimony of both of these witnesses was integral in the conviction, but for the purpose of this post, I will focus only on Mr. Johnston as he was more closely involved in the crime.

Mr. Johnston provided testimony detailing the accused’s involvement in the crime. In his confession, he explained how he and the accused planned their crime before hand as well as 1the specific acts that the accused performed during the break and enter, such as rendering the victim unconscious by putting him in a sleeper hold, cutting the house’s phone line, and telling Mr. Johnston that he slashed the victim’s tire. Mr. Johnston’s testimony was significant in identifying the accused as a perpetrator of the crime of breaking and entering.Should a Warning Have Been Applied to Mr. Johnston?


Ultimately, the appeal was refused, with the judge restating that the application of the warning is at the discretion of the trial judge, and it was decided that no error at law was made. However, the court certainly could have applied the Vetrovec witness standard on the testimony of Mr. Johnston, given the fact that he was an accomplice in the crime. It could be argued that the fact that he was given a plea deal made it even more important that the warning be given, because the motivation of doing a good job of ‘snitching’ on his partner could have caused him to play up certain facts about the events to try to make himself look less at fault than his co-accused. In this case, it would be reasonable that the jury be given the warning so that they could take the testimony with a grain of salt. On the other hand, it could also be argued that Mr. J would be extra careful to stick to the truth, in case any misstep in his story proved unsound enough to get his plea deal taken away, and this would make him an even more reliable witness. Should the Warning be Used at All?


The Vetrovec warning is used for witnesses who are suspected to be unsavoury. If there is reasonable suspicion about a witness lying, then why allow them to testify at all? Sometimes, the testimony of an unsavoury witness will be the only evidence available to a jury, so it is necessary, but when there is measurable risk to the credibility of said witness, there is good reason to inform the jury of their character. Allowing the jury the opportunity to give an extra degree of scrutiny in these cases would at least give the witness a chance to be aware that they are under special scrutiny. This could cause them to be more truthful than they would have otherwise been.


In closing, any procedure that that judge has discretion in applying will attract criticism from the side that the judge’s discretion does not favour. At the least, a clearer set of guidelines from the courts as to when exactly it should be applied would likely help to prevent more disputes and appeals based on the ambiguity of the application of this procedure in the future.


Image Description: A masked intruder, wielding a knife, enters a home as an elderly man sits inside, highlighting a tense and dangerous confrontation.
Image Description: A masked intruder, wielding a knife, enters a home as an elderly man sits inside, highlighting a tense and dangerous confrontation.

Sources

R v Pendl 2019 MBCA 89

R v Vetrovec 1982 CarswellBC 663

“Canadian Criminal Evidence/Credibility/Disreputable and Unsavoury Witnesses” (8 Nov 2019),


  • Facebook Basic Black
  • Twitter Basic Black

© 2023 Jochelson, Trask

The content on this website is provided for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal or other professional advice or an opinion of any kind. Users of this website are, in all matters, advised to seek specific legal advice by contacting licensed legal counsel for any and all legal issues. Robsoncrim.com does not warrant or guarantee the quality, accuracy or completeness of any information on this website. All items and works published on this website, regardless of their original date of publication, should not be relied upon as accurate, timely or fit for any particular purpose.

bottom of page