top of page

Searching Through Trash Left for Disposal: Invasion of Privacy?

A Broggy - law student
Dec 10, 2019
5 min read

Updated: 3 days ago

Author: A Broggy


What R. v. Patrick, a Supreme Court of Canada case heard in 2009, tells us about the level of privacy we can expect to have regarding trash left out for disposal. Every day we throw away our old bills, receipts, and used belongings, sending them off to the landfill where they are never to be seen again. Many of these items contain information about our day-to-day lives ranging from the remnants of our meals, to documents with private matters contained therein.


The Supreme Court of Canada heard a case in 2009, R. v. Patrick, which dealt with the issue of whether or not police officers were justified in searching through garbage left out for collection in order to retrieve incriminating evidence to be used against the accused. There is an expectation of privacy which exists in respect to the belongings that are contained within the boundaries of our property; however, cases examined in The Disappearance of Criminal Law: Police Powers and the Supreme Court show that our expectation of privacy may not be as encompassing as one might think (Jochelson, Kramar, & Doerksen 2014). Is it reasonable to expect that our garbage, items destined for the dump, be included as some of these private belongings?


The decision that the court came to in R. v. Patrick may suggest not. In R. v. Patrick, police had a suspicion that Patrick was operating an Ecstasy lab. They began collecting evidence from Patrick’s garbage which had been left out for collection. With the paraphernalia that was found within the trash, the police were able to attain a warrant to search the property in question. Patrick was convicted of “unlawfully producing, possessing and trafficking a controlled substance”; however, Patrick claims that the evidence found in the trash which led to the search of his home was a breach of his s. 8 right in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. It is important to note that the garbage left for collection still remained on Patrick’s property; the significance of this information is that police officers would have had to reach over the property line in order to obtain the evidence which they found. Section 8 of the Charter secures Canadian citizens “against unreasonable search or seizure”, a right intended to protect our privacy, preventing our belongings from being rummaged through without good reason. It has become increasingly difficult to establish this right when police officers are tasked with the surveillance of communities in order to prevent the occurrence of criminal activity, especially when some of this surveillance is done through ‘justifiable’ breach of privacy to collect evidence.


In this case, the court used the Tessling Factors (R. v. Tessling 2004) to determine whether or not there was a reasonable expectation of privacy to be had in the appellant’s garbage, and if there was, whether this expectation of privacy had been violated by the police conduct (R. v. Patrick 2009: para. 26-28). The court began by examining what was the “subject matter of the alleged search”, which was determined by the court of appeal to be garbage; however, Justice Binnie noted that the more important issue regarding the subject matter at hand was not just the garbage but the information that the garbage contained (Patrick, para. 30).


The next issue that the court had to consider was the matter of whether or not the appellant’s garbage had been abandoned. Both cases of R. v. Stillman (1997) and R. v. Tessling (2004) “identified garbage as a “classic” instance of abandonment” (Patrick, para. 55). In Patrick, Justice Binnie determined that the abandonment of the appellant’s garbage “occurred when the appellant placed his garbage bags for collection in the open container at the back of his property adjacent to the lot line”, and continued by explaining that had the garbage been left elsewhere, such as within the garage, abandonment would not have occurred (Patrick, para. 62). It is the placement of the garbage “at or within reach of the lot line” that gives it the status of being abandoned (Patrick, para. 62). This was an important factor in determining the outcome of the case, as when you abandon an object, you ultimately relinquish all rights to privacy of that object. It was on this basis that the court justified the police conduct of removing the garbage for evidence, i.e. that the police conduct did not amount to any intrusion of privacy on the appellant.


The court then examined whether the retrieval of garbage as evidence exposed any intimate details of the appellant’s lifestyle, as exposure of sensitive information could suffice as a breach of the appellant’s right to a reasonable expectation of privacy (Patrick, para. 71). It was determined that there was exposure of lifestyle information about the appellant; however, this was at the fault of the appellant, as the act of abandonment of the garbage was ultimately their relinquishing of any right to privacy of the contents therein (Patrick, para. 71). Although sensitive information was revealed by the police’s retrieval of evidence, it did not constitute a breach of privacy – had the appellant wished to keep the contents of their garbage private, they should have been more selective of the items that they chose to abandon at the edge of their property line.


Ultimately, the majority judgment concluded that there was no reasonable expectation of privacy in the contents of the appellant’s garbage. Therefore, there was no violation of privacy that could have occurred by the police conduct. Because the trash was abandoned, the removal of the trash by the police did not constitute an act of search and seizure, meaning that the appellant had not suffered a s.8 breach of the Charter (Patrick, para. 73).


In concurrence, Justice Abella stated that there is indeed a reasonable expectation of privacy to be had for our garbage left on the curb for collection, as these belongings “may contain the most intensely personal and private information about ourselves” (Patrick, para. 76). Abella J. voices that police must have a “reasonable suspicion that a crime has been or is likely to be committed” if they wish to hunt through our garbage for evidence (Patrick, para. 77). Abella J. also noted that garbage may be seen as abandoned, but that this is abandonment of the physical objects, and NOT the personal information that they may reveal (Patrick, para. 85). Because the police had sufficient reason to believe that the appellant had been committing a crime, Abella J. concurs that there was no breach of right under s.8 of the Charter.


As Abella J. summarizes, our abandonment of garbage for collection does not mean that we are consequently abandoning our right to privacy of that garbage (Patrick, para. 89). Based on how the majority of the court decided the case of R. v. Patrick, you may want to think twice about what you leave on your curb for disposal, as you never know who might be rummaging through it and what they might find. When it comes to our trash, we can expect to have a diminished expectation of privacy from the moment that we place it on the curb for collection.


Image Description: A police officer carefully inspects a dumpster, searching for potential evidence in an alleyway investigation.
Image Description: A police officer carefully inspects a dumpster, searching for potential evidence in an alleyway investigation.

Case List:

R. v. Patrick

R. v. Tessling

R. v. Stillman

  • Facebook Basic Black
  • Twitter Basic Black

© 2023 Jochelson, Trask

The content on this website is provided for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal or other professional advice or an opinion of any kind. Users of this website are, in all matters, advised to seek specific legal advice by contacting licensed legal counsel for any and all legal issues. Robsoncrim.com does not warrant or guarantee the quality, accuracy or completeness of any information on this website. All items and works published on this website, regardless of their original date of publication, should not be relied upon as accurate, timely or fit for any particular purpose.

bottom of page